Hello dear
Welcome To Crusty's Pizza
Crusty's Pizza, located in McCall, Idaho, is a charming eatery celebrated for its exceptional pizza and warm ambiance. Renowned for its creative and traditional pizza offerings, it features a thin, crispy sourdough crust crafted in-house. Diners rave about unique options like the Smokejumper pizza, made with local ingredients such as elk sausage and cranberries. The inviting atmosphere is enhanced by friendly staff, making every visit memorable. With a diverse selection of beers on tap and live music during winter evenings, Crusty's Pizza is perfect for a post-adventure meal, embodying a true taste of local Idaho charm.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Margherita
P&P
Build your Own Pizza 12"
US$12.00
Formaggio
West Coast
Roasted Veggie
Mediterranean
Butcher Block
Smokejumper
About
Crusty's Pizza
Welcome to Crusty's Pizza, a gem nestled in the heart of McCall, Idaho, at 214 Lenora St. This cozy pizza joint has quickly gained a reputation for being a haven for pizza lovers, and it's easy to see why. With a menu that strikes the perfect balance between creative concoctions and beloved classics, Crusty's Pizza is poised to become your go-to destination, whether you're recovering from a day on the slopes or simply indulging in a comforting meal.
From the moment you step inside, you're greeted by a warm atmosphere that invites you to unwind and savor every bite. The attentive and friendly staff make you feel right at home, as they expertly guide you through their unique offerings. It's not just pizza—though their selection is truly impressive. With options like the Smokejumper pizza, which features mouthwatering elk sausage paired with cranberries and jalapeños on a perfectly crispy sourdough crust, your taste buds will find themselves dancing with delight.
The care put into food preparation is evident, with the kitchen sourcing local ingredients and crafting their own sourdough in-house. Customers rave about the thin crust that holds up beautifully under their delicious toppings, from pepperoni to sun-dried tomatoes. Meredith Baker's review highlights the exceptional balance of flavors that Crusty's delivers: “the crust was so well done it held up the heaviest yummy packed slice!” It's clear that every aspect of the dishes is thoughtfully executed.
But Crusty's offers more than just pizza. With a commendable selection of garden salads and local beers on tap, you can complement your meal with a refreshing drink. Kenneth Ashley vividly describes the enchanting experience of enjoying live music by a crackling fire—perfect for those chilly winter nights in McCall. It's a full sensory experience that goes beyond just dining; it's about creating memories.
Crusty's Pizza is not just another eatery; it is a community hub where locals and visitors alike come together to celebrate great food and camaraderie. If you're in the area—perhaps after a thrilling day at Brundage Mountain—be sure to make Crusty's Pizza your next stop. With its inviting ambiance, friendly service, and undeniably delicious food, Crusty's Pizza has carved out a niche as a must-visit destination in southwestern Idaho.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great local pizza place. Creative pizza options as well as excellent traditional pizza. But it’s more than pizza, also had a great garden salad. Good drink offerings as well as a variety of beer on tap. Very friendly staff. Prices reasonable. I was there in the winter but it looks like music is very much a part of this place. Certainly give this place a visit. ”
“ After skiing Brundage all day, this place was the best decision for dinner! We were greeted by the biggest smiles and the really nice guy who took our order seemed genuinely happy to serve us and make us pizza. Also the trees outside were dazzling with Christmas lights, which made me happy lol. We chose the 12” Smokejumper pizza which had elk sausage, cranberries, jalapenos and feta. It was SO DELICIOUS. The sourdough crust (made in-house) was thin and crispy. To top it off he gave us two little containers of I think roasted garlic sauce which was fire. The pizza with the sauce was so juicy, flavorful and exciting. And the man working was a genuinely happy guy, we felt so welcomed and left happier than we entered. Something to note, they don’t sell by the slice! Our 12” smokejumper pizza came out to about 26 and it fed my husband and I. Will definitely come back if skiing in the area again! ”
“ OMG!!! Had pizza there tonight! Best pizza I have had in a long time!! The thin crust was perfect! We did a half pepperoni, half artichoke, sun dried tomatoes, Italian sausage, and Parmesan cheese. The crust was so well done it held up the heaviest yummy packed slice! The service was great and the guys working were super nice!! I’m stoked and will definitely be back!! ”
“ We walked out of our truck and immediately where just absolutely drawn to the smokey sweet smell of peppers being skillfully smoked for the house made habenaro honey... but was quickly embraced by the absolute quaint atmosphere of this pizza place... the owner Brain was ever so gracious to come to our table and tell me the story of the place and about their menu and their pursuit to continue to stick to the tradition of the original owner to source good local ingredients to keep a wide selection of also local beers and very choice wines.... they do live music every Friday during the winter as well as a fire crackling in the hearth. They recommended their signature pie and it (the SmokeJumper) didn't disappoint it paired with a Big Crusty and a couple of local draft beers was an absolute must if you find yourself in or near McCall Idaho...the absolute best pizza in south western Idaho... hands down ”
“ In March we went to Crusty's for dinner to see if their pizza was tasty. We were having a wedding in May near McCall and the bride and groom wanted pizza! Crusty's was so good, we were sold. Working with Nate and Brian on how best to take care of a large crowd and still have good tasty pizza with the amazing crusty crust was great. They are super helpful and accommodating. Their communication was great. I highly recommend Crusty's! ”
“ Amazing pizza awesome staff the owner is one of a kind gentleman give the shirt off his back kind of guy. Sour dough crust is out of this world. The little crusty is bomb can’t go wrong with a build you own pizza. Music during the week in the summer fire pit for winter cold beer year round. ”
“ Awsome food, awsome service, awsome atmosphere. For me it's the best spot in town to stop in. ”
“ This was the first time in McCall ID, and this place came recommended. We tried it, and we were not disappointed! It's a quaint little place with not many frills. But it's all about the food! The pizza might not be pretty as pizzas go, but it's the taste that counts, and the pizza delivered! The crust looks undercooked, but I tell you it was not! It was a crunchy thin crust that was perfect! It was light brown on the bottom and not burnt at all! I had the 4 little pigs with pineapple, and it was a phenomenal pizza. We sat outside, and it was a really nice evening to enjoy some great pizza! My daughter had the Formage Pizza with chicken on a gluten-free crust! She loved it! You can have any pizza on the gouten-free crust! A must try in McCall! ”